Aluminum vs Copper Gutters: Which is Best for Your Chicago Home? [Complete Guide]

By Mike Thompson, Lead Gutter Installation Specialist at Chicago Gutter Heroes 8/18/2025
Choosing between aluminum and copper gutters for your Chicago home? This comprehensive guide compares costs, durability, and maintenance requirements of both materials. Learn why aluminum remains the popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners, while copper offers premium benefits for those seeking long-term value. Discover how each material performs in Chicago's challenging weather conditions and get expert insights on making the best choice for your property.

Chicago's extreme weather demands gutters that can withstand everything from summer storms to winter ice. When choosing between aluminum and copper gutters for your Chicago home, several factors come into play. Let's explore which material might be the best investment for your property.

Aluminum Gutters: The Popular Choice

Aluminum gutters remain the most common choice for Chicago homes, and for good reason:

  • Cost-effective ($4-$8 per linear foot installed)
  • Lightweight and easy to install
  • Resistant to rust
  • Available in multiple colors
  • Low maintenance requirements

Copper Gutters: The Premium Option

While more expensive, copper gutters offer distinct advantages that many Riverside and Cicero homeowners find worthwhile:

  • Exceptional durability (50+ years lifespan)
  • Develops an attractive patina
  • Adds significant home value
  • Naturally antimicrobial
  • Superior weather resistance

Cost Comparison

The price difference between materials is significant:

  • Aluminum: $4-$8 per linear foot installed
  • Copper: $15-$25 per linear foot installed

Performance in Chicago Weather

Chicago's climate can be particularly harsh on gutters. Our seamless gutter installation experts find that both materials handle local weather conditions differently:

Aluminum Gutters:

  • Good performance in rain and snow
  • May dent from falling branches
  • Requires regular gutter cleaning

Copper Gutters:

  • Superior snow and ice handling
  • Resistant to extreme temperature changes
  • Less likely to sag or bend

Maintenance Considerations

As discussed in our guide to seasonal gutter maintenance, proper care is essential regardless of material choice:

Aluminum Maintenance:

  • Regular cleaning required
  • May need occasional repainting
  • Consider gutter covers for added protection

Copper Maintenance:

  • Minimal maintenance needed
  • Natural patina requires no treatment
  • Higher initial cost but lower long-term maintenance

Making Your Decision

Consider these factors when choosing:

  • Budget constraints
  • Home's architectural style
  • Long-term plans for the property
  • Local architectural requirements

Before winter arrives, ensure your gutters are ready by reviewing our guide on preparing gutters for winter.

Professional Installation is Key

Whether you choose aluminum or copper, professional installation is crucial for optimal performance. Chicago Gutter Heroes provides expert installation services throughout Chicago, including Maywood and surrounding areas.

Ready to upgrade your home's gutter system? Contact Chicago Gutter Heroes at (719) 215-2400 for a free consultation and estimate. Our experts will help you choose the perfect gutter solution for your Chicago home.

Need Professional gutter contractors Services?

Contact Chicago Gutter Heroes today for expert gutter contractors services in Chicago.

Call (719) 215-2400